Breaking News
August 17
by Morgan Blake
Attorney General Todd Blanche says the FBI will continue supporting the Nancy Guthrie investigation but does not plan to take full control of the case
Attorney General Todd Blanche said the FBI will continue to provide “significant assistance” in the investigation of Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, but he doesn’t believe a full federal takeover of the case is necessarily the right approach. The comments came Sunday as the investigation into the missing Arizona woman reaches the six-month mark without any public break, Blanche said. Guthrie, mother of NBC Today co-anchor Savanna Guthrie, went missing from her Tucson-area home in February. The case has attracted national attention and involved local, state and federal law enforcement agencies. “We’re working very closely with state and local authorities and we’re providing manpower and forensic assistance,” Blanche said on NBC News’ Kristen Welker on Meet the Press. He said the FBI does not need to take over the whole investigation. The comments come as questions remain about the direction of the investigation and whether more federal resources could produce new leads. Blanche said the Justice Department will continue to support investigators, with local authorities taking the lead investigative role.
Blanche’s comments are the latest in a line of clear explanations about the role of the federal government in the Nancy Guthrie investigation. “The FBI is already heavily engaged in assisting state and local investigators and federal involvement doesn’t require Washington to assume total control of the case,” he said. The attorney general said federal authorities are providing manpower and forensic assistance, which shows the FBI is still supplying investigative resources even as local law enforcement remains at the heart of the operation. “The federal government will continue to assist in making sure that the investigation is done properly,” Blanche said. His view is that officials are looking to bolster the ongoing investigation, not supplant the agencies already heading it up. The difference is important because a federal takeover could dramatically change the way the investigation is coordinated. Blanche's approach, by comparison, leaves the state and local authorities in charge, with federal agencies able to provide specialised resources. The attorney general acknowledged the frustration over the absence of a public resolution. He said he sympathised with Guthrie's family and wished he had a major update to offer. The case has drawn exceptional national attention because of Guthrie's connection to Savanna Guthrie, a top journalist for NBC. Despite the publicity, investigators have yet to publicly announce a resolution. So Blanche’s comments provide a better picture of how the government is currently handling things: continued federal assistance, but no immediate move to give overall authority to the FBI.
The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie remains one of Arizona’s most highly publicised missing-person cases. She was last seen in the Tucson area and authorities began investigating the circumstances around her disappearance. The case has required extensive cooperation between local officials and federal investigators. Authorities have tried to piece together what happened and identify potential leads, with investigative resources provided by the FBI. The absence of a conclusive resolution has maintained the public’s interest in the ongoing investigation. Blanche’s remarks indicate that federal investigators remain on the job even as the Justice Department does not consider a full takeover necessary at this point. Local investigators have partnered with federal authorities, and the FBI has brought in expertise that smaller law-enforcement agencies may not have on staff. This cooperation may include forensic analysis, investigative support and specialised personnel. The case has also put pressure on officials to offer updates while protecting sensitive investigative information. Authorities often won’t release details that could jeopardise potential evidence, investigative techniques or future prosecutions. Balance is shown in Blanche's remarks. He said he understood the family's desire for answers, but said the investigation is ongoing "behind the scenes." Just because there has not been a public breakthrough does not mean the investigative work has stopped. There have been few developments made public, allowing federal and local agencies to continue sifting thru evidence, reviewing information and following up on leads. But for the Guthrie family, the long uncertainty continues to be very hard to bear. Even without a formal transfer of control to the FBI, the continued involvement of the Justice Department means federal resources remain available as investigators continue to seek answers.
However, local authorities would remain in the driver’s seat, and the FBI would not have pulled out of the investigation. Specifically, Blanche said, federal agents are pitching in on a number of fronts, including manpower and forensics support. That would enable federal investigators to bring specialised skills to the investigation while maintaining the structure of the investigation. The FBI often partners with state and local law enforcement agencies on complex missing person cases, particularly when investigations have extensive forensic, technological or investigative requirements. The Guthrie case has received a lot of federal involvement because of the national attention around the disappearance and the seriousness of the circumstances under investigation. Blanche’s statement also leaves room for the FBI to play a bigger role if circumstances change. It’s something that can be evaluated as the investigation continues, whether federal investigators eventually take the lead, he said. But for now, the Justice Department appears to prefer cooperation over a full takeover. That approach could give investigators already involved in the case continuity while tapping federal expertise. The approach also avoids undue interference with an investigation that has already involved months of work, evidence gathering and inter-agency coordination. But the continued lack of resolution also puts pressure on authorities to make sure all avenues of investigation are being pursued. The help the FBI provides is a resource, but Blanche’s comments make it clear that federal involvement does not mean the federal government will take control.
This is especially a difficult time for Nancy Guthrie’s family, and Blanche’s latest comments come at that time. But six months after her disappearance the investigation is still open and the public is still waiting for news of what happened to her. Blanche admitted the emotional strain of the case and said he wished he could provide an update. His words underscore the difficulty for investigators when a high-profile case drags on for a long time with no breakthrough made public. Savanna Guthrie has publicly talked about her mother’s disappearance before, helping to keep national attention on the search. For investigators, the priority remains finding reliable evidence and determining what happened, rather than merely increasing the visibility of the investigation. So the choice not to have the FBI take over formally isn’t a sign that the federal government doesn’t see the case as important. Instead, Blanche says federal officials will continue to share resources with state and local authorities. It is unclear whether that approach will ultimately yield new information. Authorities are trying to get a clearer picture on the circumstances of Guthrie’s disappearance and the investigation could continue with forensic analysis, evidence review and the pursuit of new leads. For now, Blanche’s statement cements the federal government’s stance: the FBI will play a major role, but local and state investigators will still lead the probe. The search is in another phase and the central question remains unanswered – what happened to Nancy Guthrie and where is she? The Justice Department said it will continue to back the investigators until those questions are answered.
Morgan Blake is a U.S. investigative journalist specializing in government accountability, corporate misconduct, and public-interest reporting.
Newsflash: